Skip to main content

Kindle Lending Library, an early review.

Amazon announced today the Kindle Lending Library which allows Kindle users to "borrow" books.

This is a concept I've been hoping for, but I think Amazon is doing it wrong! In order to borrow books you must be a member of Amazon Prime, their annual fee VIP shopper's club.



I've always disputed the value of Amazon Prime. At $79 a year, it's pretty easy to save. You get free shipping on every order. You also get downloadable television shows and movies (fewer than Netflix, but a reasonable selection of 13,000 titles) for unlimited viewing.  But let's face it. If you love TV shows and movies, Netflix is a better service at a comparable price (for instant watch).  If you read a lot, free shipping is nice, but you get free shipping on every order over $25 anyhow. I don't know about you, but I've never walked away from Amazon with an order less than $25.  Prime members get priority shipping,  but I've never been disappointed with the timeliness of Amazon's regular shipping.

You have to own a Kindle device. Today you can get them as low as $79, but I paid $400+ for my first Kindle, and my current Kindle was around $200.

You must own a Kindle and be a member of Amazon Prime to use the lending library. I'm sure there is lots of overlap between these two groups of frequent customers, but there are certainly many frequent customers, like myself, who are one or the other.

Here's the kick in the teeth, in my opinion. You can only "borrow" one book per month. If you subscribe to Amazon Prime, your cost is a little over $6.50 monthly. There are thousands of books available on Kindle, including top sellers for less than that price. Furthermore, the lending library is a very limited selection compared to the overall potential. They are currently boasting "100 current and former New York Times bestsellers".

I'm not bashing Amazon. I absolutely love the company, and I love what they've done for Internet commerce overall. However, in my mind they haven't established any value for their Amazon Prime service, and this first version of a Kindle Lending Library is almost insulting.

I think there are three reasonable alternative variations to a Kindle Lending Library.

  1. Larger annual fee -- unlimited downloads, large selection, no due dates
  2. Small annual fee -- downloads limited by popularity (i.e. xxx copies available at the time) with a waiting list or queue, due dates with one-time renewal, large selection
  3. Free for Kindle owners -- one free download monthly, smaller selection

Kindle owners are generally frequent readers. Additionally, there are quite a few very low cost or free books available. A good lending library would reward frequent customers, and give opportunities to authors to get wider audiences for their books, without giving them away.

I like the Kindle is a marketplace leader, but they won't be there for long if other e-book readers offer better lending libraries.

For a company that's always done a good job of demonstrating value, Amazon Prime and the Kindle Lending Library are pretty poor representations in my opinion.

Share your opinion below, please.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

People who died on the toilet (real people and fictional characters)

Famous people who died on the toilet. Here is an extensive list of real people who died on the throne. Elvis Presley died of an overdose, falling off the toilet into a pile of his own vomit. Judy Garland died of an overdose discovered slumped over her toilet. King George II of Britain suffered a heart attack while sitting on the toilet. Wenceslaus III of Bohemia assassinated with a spear while he sat on the toilet. Godfrey IV, Duke of Lower Lorraine, was attacked by an assassin while sitting on the toilet. He died a week after the attack. Japanese warlord Uesugi Kenshin was assassinated with a spear while sitting on the toilet. British author Evelyn Waugh, who coincidently also married a woman named Evelyn, died on his toilet. Some believe he drowned in it, however his official cause of death was heart failure. Famed architect Louis Kahn suffered a heart attack and died on the toilet in New York City’s Penn station. One of the early Christian preachers, Arius, had been condemned as a…

More Realistic Anniversary Gift Traditions

New Anniversary Gifts Destined to become Traditional My wife and I have been married for 20 years today. Over the past 20 years I made efforts each year to observe the traditional anniversary gifts. Some of them are certainly more difficult than others, and many of them are hard to find gift worthy in the modern age.
Therefore, I offer you a modern take on anniversary gifts. How many of these will become traditional?
First Anniversary – The Ramen Noodle anniversary. Let’s face it, you blew $30,000 on the wedding, and your student loan debt hasn’t gone anywhere. Share a Cup O’ Noodles. Eat with chopsticks on the floor because you can’t yet afford a couch.
Second Anniversary – The Puppy Anniversary. She’s been looking at you with those eyes that say she wants to start a family, but you just bought a new couch. Get her a puppy instead.
Third Anniversary – The Kinky Lingerie Anniversary. Leather, silk or lace can re-fire the engines after a year of flannel pajamas that smell like the puppy,…

How United Airlines Should Have Handled the Situation

United Airlines is under fire for a viral video that shows them removing a passenger forcibly from an airplane bound for Louisville Kentucky.
Here are the bullets:

The plane was already loaded and full.The airline needed to fly four employees to Louisville Kentucky on the plane. The employees needed to go to prevent another plane from departing late.The airline offered $800 in compensation to the first four people who would volunteer to give up their seats. No one took the offer.The airline went to a lottery, drawing for people at random. These four people were asked to leave the plane, and they would receive the compensation.One of the passengers refused to leave. It's unclear how things escalated, however he was removed by security officers. Reports are conflicting about whether the officers were police officers, TSA workers, or airline staff.The gentleman was literally physically dragged down the aisle receiving while screaming in protest and physically abused in the process.Ap…